Demystifying Bioidentical Progesterone vs. Progestin: A Guide to Hormone Replacement Therapy for Perimenopause and Menopause
Let's dive into the world of hormone replacement therapy (HRT) and demystify the differences between bioidentical progesterone and progestin.
Composition
Bioidentical progesterone (or oral micronized progesterone, OMP), is derived from natural sources like yam or soy, and shares the same molecular structure as the progesterone our bodies produce. It's like a twin that can bind to progesterone receptors and evoke similar responses.
Progestins, on the other hand, are laboratory-created synthetic hormones. They function similarly to progesterone but have a different molecular structure. Think of them as mimickers that try to replicate progesterone's effects but might not be chemically identical.
Metabolism
Bioidentical progesterone goes through natural enzymatic processes in our bodies, just like the progesterone we make. It follows the same metabolic pathways, getting recognized and broken down as expected. Progestins, being synthetic compounds, have a different metabolic journey compared to natural progesterone. They may take alternative routes, which could lead to the production of metabolites distinct from those generated by bioidentical progesterone. These differences can influence efficacy and potential side effects.
Side Effects
Bioidentical progesterone tends to be well-tolerated, with fewer reported side effects compared to progestins. Some women mention reduced bloating, breast tenderness, and mood swings when using bioidentical progesterone.
Progestins, due to their synthetic nature and potential structural variations, may carry a higher risk of side effects. If you ever had a bad reaction to the hormones in birth control, you may not tolerate progestins. These can include breast tenderness, bloating, weight gain, mood changes, and an increased likelihood of specific cardiovascular conditions. Remember, individual responses may vary.
Personalization
Bioidentical progesterone comes from both the regular pharmacy (Prometrium) or can be made in a compounding pharmacy. A compounding pharmacy can customize progesterone doses and fillers to match your unique needs. Compounded bioidentical hormones are tailored to your specific hormonal requirements, allowing for personalized dosing and potentially better symptom management. Prometrium is in a peanut oil base, which isn’t compatible with tree nut allergies.
Progestins, being standardized synthetic hormones, usually come in predetermined dosages and formulations. They may not offer the same level of customization as bioidentical progesterone.
I personally only ever use bio-identical hormones with my patients, due to improved tolerability. Some research has shown that progestins may contribute to higher cancer rates, but this hasn’t been shown in bioidentical progesterone.
If you’re interested in how bioidentical hormones can help improve your perimenopause and menopause journey, reach out! Together, we'll find the best approach for your individual needs and make those hormonal transitions a bit smoother. Remember, you're not alone on this journey! I’ll help you reclaim control of your hormonal bliss.
Meet Your Doctor
Hi, I’m Dr. Caitlin Fanning, ND (Naturopathic Doctor),
I help women who are struggling with hormone imbalances, fatigue, and infertility optimize their hormones and get their life back so they can feel like their best self.
If you're ready to take charge of your health and make real, lasting changes to your energy, your hormones, or your overall well-being, I would love to talk more!